Dairy Study Uses 7 White Men to Represent All Americans

Nov 17, 2020

Why is chocolate milk so ingrained in sports culture? Milk has science on its side. The industry pays for studies that are designed to yield positive results, and these (often barely statistically significant) results are turned into national advertising campaigns to convince consumers to buy more milk. The Built with Chocolate Milk campaign cites this study to uphold milk as the optimal post-workout recovery beverage. This particular study claims that milk hydrates better than water or sports drinks, but when we looked deeper at the actual methodology and the numbers, we found the industry’s interpretation to be extremely flawed. 

Funded by Dairy

Funded by the National Dairy Council of Ireland, the researchers were pressured to achieve results that favored dairy. Most industry-funded researchers accomplish this by designing the study in a way that they are confident will benefit a particular product. The science is true, but the methodology is rigged. In this study, researchers assured favorable milk outcomes by designing a highly controlled scenario not applicable to real life. 

The 7 Participants

First, it is necessary to look at the participants. The Built with Chocolate Milk campaign claims chocolate milk is essential for all athletes—no matter their race or gender. However, only seven white, lactose-persistent, Irish men with an average age of 26 years were chosen for this study. The lack of diversity is laughable, and this minuscule number of participants is not significant enough to yield conclusive results—especially not for a diverse population. 

Study Methodology

These seven participants underwent two trials of dehydration and rehydration. The participants fasted (no food or water) for five hours then exercised in a warm environment until they had lost two percent of their body mass. Then, over the course of five hours, participants rehydrated with either one percent milk, Powerade, or water until they had consumed 150 percent of their body mass loss. 

Study Results

Researchers found that the milk drinkers had a lower urine output, higher net fluid balance, and higher plasma osmolality. These markers informed the conclusion that milk hydrates better than water or Powerade. However, what these results really show is that, most likely, milk stays in the body longer and causes water retention. For the vast majority of people, water retention is not a desired trait. 

Further, hydration markers such as sodium level and CTproAVP remained constant amongst all three beverages. These factors may present a clearer picture of one’s state of hydration—not water retention—and yet milk had no superior effect in these two areas. 

Another factor not addressed in the conclusion is the fact that the milk drinkers restored their caloric deficit by 106 percent, meaning they overconsumed what they needed. If people exercise to lose or maintain their weight, drinking milk (or chocolate milk) post-workout could derail the work they just put in. 

Slanted Conclusions

Finally, the scenario is simply not applicable to real life. Most people do not fast for five hours post-workout. There is no way to tell how hydration would be affected with food. Also, most people are not 26-year-old Irish men. The results are for a very select group of individuals and cannot be applied to an entire population. 

Milk has science on its side, but that doesn’t mean we should trust it. Unfortunately, studies can be manipulated and the industry can pick and choose what results to feature. Milk is not an optimal exercise recovery drink, and it doesn’t do a body good. Find out what the ads aren’t telling you here

5 Tips to Maintain Strong Bones and Prevent Osteoporosis

According to the National Osteoporosis Foundation, approximately 10 million Americans suffer from osteoporosis and another 44 million have been diagnosed with low bone density.1 Milk has often been purported to “build strong bones” a myth that remains pervasive today...

Is Whey Protein Healthy? Probably Not

Medically reviewed by Dr. Lucky (Lakshman Mulpuri MD)   What is whey protein? Whey, a protein complex derived from cow’s milk, is the liquid byproduct of the cheesemaking process. Next, the liquid whey is filtered and purified through various processes to remove...

Mythbusting Soy Part 1: Women’s Health and Hormones

Women's Health and Hormones It’s no secret that women run this world. Especially healthy, strong, energized women who are fueled by soy. Despite the bounty of misinformation out there, soy products like tofu, tempeh, soy milk, and edamame are incredibly beneficial for...

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This